Essential technologies help deliver and secure the site.

Optional analytics and advertising cookies are disabled on this site.

Read about cookies and privacy

The Stymphalian Birds: Heracles and the creatures of the marsh

Editorial artwork: History Hogs
In this article

Heracles cannot solve every problem by walking up to it and hitting it. For the Stymphalian Birds, he first has to get a flock out of the cover around a lake. The solution is noise: bronze rattles supplied by Athena startle the birds into the open. Library 2.5.6.

This is commonly numbered the sixth of his labours. Ancient accounts agree more readily on the racket than on exactly what happens to the birds afterwards.

Athena supplies the noise

The Library attributed to Apollodorus places the birds at Stymphalus in Arcadia. Countless birds have gathered at a lake surrounded by deep woodland, taking refuge from wolves. Heracles is unsure how to drive them out. Athena gives him bronze castanets, or clappers, which she has received from Hephaestus. The equipment has a maker and a giver; they are not the same deity. Library 2.5.6.

From a mountain overlooking the lake, Heracles clashes the clappers. The frightened birds take flight and he shoots them. In this account the useful tool is not a more powerful arrow, but something that makes an arrow possible to use. We do not need to add a specification for Hydra-poisoned tips to tell the episode as this passage gives it.

Did Heracles kill them?

Pausanias reports the familiar story of man-eating birds shot by Heracles, then preserves a different account from the poet Peisander of Camirus: Heracles drives them away with rattles rather than killing them. That changes the outcome while keeping the noise at the centre. Description of Greece 8.22.4.

Pausanias also describes the sanctuary of Stymphalian Artemis, with representations of birds near the roof and marble maidens with birds' legs standing behind the temple. These are valuable details about the creature's local imagery. The existence of bird-footed statues does not by itself establish that the flock in the labour was originally a group of human women. Description of Greece 8.22.7.

How monstrous were the birds?

The man-eating reputation makes the flock dangerous enough. More detailed anatomy needs care. Pausanias describes Arabian birds called Stymphalian as crane-sized and ibis-like, with strong, straight beaks capable of piercing metal armour. But he immediately admits that he does not know whether these are the same kind as the old Arcadian birds. Description of Greece 8.22.5–6.

That uncertainty belongs in our account too. His discussion cannot simply be turned into a definitive size chart for the birds Heracles met. It shows an ancient writer trying to connect a famous myth with reports about animals elsewhere, while leaving the connection unresolved.

A mythical labour in a real wetland

Stymphalia is a real landscape as well as a setting for a labour. The Environment Museum of Stymphalia discusses the basin's water systems, ecology and relationship with human activity. Its exhibitions connect the lake with the lives and traditional occupations of people around it. PIOP, Environment Museum of Stymphalia.

That setting helps us picture why a story about troublesome birds could belong here. It does not prove a particular historical event behind the labour. Likewise, interpreting the episode as an example of resourcefulness is a reading of its action, rather than a universal ancient explanation of what birds symbolise.

Heracles wins by changing the conditions of the encounter. Whether the birds fall to his arrows or leave the district, the clappers do the work that brute strength cannot do on its own.

Compare the Hydra and Nemean Lion, or explore other hybrids: Centaurs, Harpies, Minotaur and Sirens. Our Greek monsters guide and book guide provide wider reading.

Read next The Ceryneian Hind: Golden horns and a delicate labour

Sources and further reading

Back to the top

Follow History Hogs

Follow History Hogs via RSS