Essential technologies help deliver and secure the site.

Optional analytics and advertising cookies are disabled on this site.

Read about cookies and privacy

Rome vs Sparta: Could a phalanx stop the legions?

Editorial artwork: History Hogs
In this article

Rome and Sparta both built formidable military reputations. But how would their armies have fared against each other at their strongest?

Their historical encounters offer a starting point. The hypothetical contest is different: Julius Caesar’s Roman legions against the Spartans commanded by Pausanias.

Rome vs. Sparta: historical battles

Spartan Hoplites charging
Spartan Hoplites charging / Wikimedia Commons

Rome and Sparta fought, but not when both were at their peak. Their actual encounters belong to a different balance of power.

The Roman siege of Sparta (195 BC)

In 195 BC, Flamininus led a Roman army of around 50,000 against a Sparta already past its strongest years. His troops surrounded the city.

When the Romans attacked, the Spartans set fire to buildings near the walls. The flames blocked the advance, while the city’s narrow streets made progress harder. The tactic thwarted the siege.

The conflict, known as the “War against Nabis,” nevertheless ended in Sparta’s surrender. Nabis, its tyrant king and last free ruler, remained in charge as a Roman client. Rome wanted Sparta strong enough to counterbalance the growing Achaean League.

The siege of Gythium

After Flamininus and his legions left, Macedon, the Aetolians, a stronger Achaean League and a weakened Sparta remained the major regional powers. Opposing Roman involvement, the Aetolians encouraged Nabis to recover his lost territory.

In 192 BC, Nabis used his rebuilt army and navy to besiege Gythium. The Achaeans appealed to Rome, which sent the praetor Atilius with a fleet and Flamininus as envoy. Philopoemen’s Achaean forces did not wait for them: they lost a naval encounter with Sparta and failed to break its blockade on land.

Philopoemen returned to Laconia and won a victory despite an ambush. Plans to take Sparta followed, but Flamininus persuaded him to spare it. Nabis accepted terms similar to the earlier treaty.

The end of Sparta

As his position weakened, Nabis asked the Aetolians for help. Their cavalry commander, Alexamenus, killed him during a drill. Aetolian troops briefly held the palace before being driven out. Philopoemen then entered with the Achaean army and brought Sparta into the League, preserving its laws and territory without restoring the exiled warrior class.

In 189 BC, Rome allowed most hostages to return to Sparta, excluding Nabis’s deceased son. Still without a port and facing economic and political problems, Sparta captured Las, where many exiles lived. The Achaeans demanded those responsible. The Spartans instead killed pro-Achaean citizens, left the League and sought Roman protection, which Rome did not oppose.

In 188 BC, Philopoemen invaded northern Laconia. He massacred anti-Achaean people, demolished Nabis’s walls, restored exiles and replaced Spartan law with Achaean law. Sparta’s prominence ended as Achaea became the leading power in the Peloponnese.

Rome vs. Sparta at their peak

Before comparing the armies, we need to choose what counts as each side’s peak.

Sparta at its peak

Battle of Thermopylae Spartans and Persians
Spartans and Persians at the Battle of Thermopylae / Wikimedia Commons

The Spartan Hegemony, mainly in the last quarter of the fourth century BC, marked Sparta’s greatest territorial and political reach. Spartan commanders governed local regions as the city extended its control across Greece.

Sparta was classical Greece’s greatest land power. Its warrior society fought in the phalanx formation widely used across the Greek world.

Boys entered the agoge at seven. Training combined physical conditioning, sport and cunning with poetry, music, academic study and politics. Those who completed it by 30 gained full Spartan citizenship.

For its military peak, however, this comparison looks back to the Second Persian War, when Spartans led the united Greek armies against Persia.

Sparta supplied 45,000 men: 5,000 Spartiates, or full citizen soldiers; 5,000 other Lacedaemonian hoplites, the perioeci; and 35,000 helots.

Rome at its peak

Portrait of Julius Caesar (oil on canvas). Based on bust of the ruler from the British Museum.
Portrait of Julius Caesar / Mark James Miller Wikimedia Commons

Rome offers several candidates. Trajan’s armies reached its greatest territorial extent. Aurelian reunited a fractured Roman world, while Scipio Africanus’s legions defeated Hannibal, Rome’s greatest historical adversary.

For this contest, the choice is Caesar’s legions. He began his Gallic campaign with four and returned with eleven, each comprising 6,000 men.

They were experienced, fiercely loyal troops who had subdued Gaul and would defeat Pompey’s legions. Dan Carlin has argued that they could have beaten any Western European army for the next thousand years.

Who would win: Rome or Sparta?

Sparta vs Rome

In a hypothetical battle between Caesar’s Romans and Pausanias’s Spartans, Rome would likely win decisively.

Its flexible tactics, greater resources and disciplined legions would give it the advantage in most engagements, potentially turning victory into a rout.

Why Rome would dominate Sparta

Roman Legion Structure
Roman Legion Structure / Conung Wikimedia Commons

Roman tactics adapted to the rigid Greek phalanx. Rome had faced Greek armies repeatedly and consistently defeated them.

Sparta’s strengths were the cohesion and discipline of its phalanx, alongside a warrior culture focused on individual excellence. Its society was more isolationist and rarely interested in large field armies. One Spartan might match a Roman in single combat; the armies are a different comparison.

Rome’s expansionist society supported a large army able to use varied strategies. Caesar’s tactical and strategic ability would add to that advantage.

Sparta’s chance would be a Thermopylae-like setting: terrain that forced a frontal clash and protected the phalanx from being flanked. Even there, facing adaptable Roman legions would be difficult.

Would that terrain give Sparta a chance, or would a different commander change the contest? The hypothetical battle leaves room to argue over both.

Read next The religion of Sparta: Gods, myths and sacred rituals

Back to the top

Follow History Hogs

Follow History Hogs via RSS