What if Constantinople had survived 1453? Culture, trade and power

Editorial artwork: History Hogs
In this article

Constantinople’s capture by the Ottomans in 1453 ended the Byzantine Empire and marked a historical turning point.

What if it had survived? How might a continuing Byzantine state have changed history?

The possibilities range from religion and culture to trade and political power.

How Constantinople fell

The fall of Constantinople in 1453 was a turning point in history that had significant consequences for the Byzantine Empire and the world.

For over a thousand years, the city had been a centre of art, learning and culture. Its fall ended the Eastern Roman, or Byzantine, Empire.

Ottoman cannon

Constantine Palaeologus the Emperor of the Greco-Romans exits fearless into the battle on 1453 May 29.
Constantine Palaeologus the Emperor of the Greco-Romans exits fearless into the battle on 1453 May 29.

Despite a valiant last stand and a heroic final speech by Constantine XI, the Ottomans, led by Mehmed II, conquered the city. Using their new superweapon, cannons, they shattered the walls of Constantinople, allowing the Ottoman forces to enter and capture the city.

The fall of Constantinople had far-reaching consequences, both for the Byzantine Empire and the rest of Europe. The Byzantine Empire had declined for centuries, and the city’s fall was the final nail in the coffin.

Remaining territories split into states including the Byzantine Greek States, Latin Empire and Despotate of Epirus.

Too weak and poorly resourced to resist, they faced an Ottoman state that kept expanding for centuries.

A new caliph

The fall of Constantinople also had a significant impact on the Ottoman Empire. The Ottomans adopted a more orthodox Islamic culture after their conquest, and Mehmed II declared himself the new Caliph of Islam, succeeding the Abbasid Caliphate.

The claim gave the Ottomans religious legitimacy and supported further expansion in the Middle East and North Africa.

Europe lost its continuous connection with the Roman Republic. Greek scholars arriving in Italy also revived interest in classical learning.

1. The Renaissance might not have begun

Greek scholars arriving in the West

The 1453 conquest removed a major intellectual centre and ended Byzantium, shifting Europe’s cultural balance.

However, it also profoundly impacted Western Europe, as scholars and intellectuals fled the city, bringing a wealth of knowledge and learning lost to the West for centuries.

Refugees carried texts unavailable in the West, including the complete Plato and Aristotle. Renewed interest in Greek and Roman culture helped create the Renaissance and its changes in art, politics, literature and philosophy.

That movement spread through Europe, preparing the way for the Age of Exploration and Scientific Revolution with new knowledge and ways of thinking.

Byzantium’s catastrophe thus also sparked a cultural and intellectual rebirth in the West.

2. The Reformation might have developed differently

Artwork of Martin Luther and the Protestant reformation

Greek-speaking Christian refugees encouraged humanist ideas that influenced Luther, Calvin and Zwingli, helping shape the Protestant Reformation.

The resulting changes in European religion and politics still have consequences today.

Without Renaissance humanism, the Reformation might have arrived later or taken another form. Individualism, critical thought and personal faith helped shape Protestantism.

Engraving by Gustav Eilers after Wilhelm Kaulbach
Engraving by Gustav Eilers after Wilhelm Kaulbach ‘The Age of Reformation’, in: Wilhelm Kaulbach’s mural in the staircase of the New Museum in Berlin, Alexander Duncker publishing house, 1871

Martin Luther, in particular, was a key figure who rejected the established authority of the Catholic Church and sought to reform it. His works, including the Ninety-Five Theses, were influenced by humanist ideals and the questioning of authority that arose from the Renaissance.

Without the fall, humanism and the Renaissance might not have developed, delaying or transforming the Reformation.

A Christian split was probably inevitable, but might have looked very different without those ideas or figures such as Luther.

3. The Age of Discovery might not have begun

McConnell
McConnell’s historical map, showing Early Voyages of the age of Discovery.

The European Age of Discovery, from the 15th to 18th centuries, is considered one of the most significant periods in history. It marked the beginning of colonialism and imperialism as European explorers embarked on many voyages of discovery to various parts of the world.

Explorers sought new trade routes because goods such as silk and spices became harder to obtain after Constantinople’s fall.

The Ottomans’ 200 years of warfare against Christian Europe forced traders to find other ways east.

Portuguese routes to India and Columbus’s arrival in the Americas followed, alongside other discoveries.

A world without that exploration is impossible to predict, but its consequences changed history permanently.

4. Spain might not have united

Artwork of Ferdinand and Isabella

The unification of Spain under Ferdinand and Isabella was a critical event in European history. The marriage of the two monarchs brought Spain’s two most powerful kingdoms together and paved the way for establishing a centralized, strong, and powerful Spanish state.

Taking Granada, Western Europe’s last Muslim state, ended the long Christian-Muslim struggle in Iberia and marked a defining step towards unity.

The Capitulation of Granada, 1492, Francisco Pradilla y Ortiz. The Surrender of Granada: The last king of Granada, Abu Abdullah Muhammad XII, hands over Granada, the last Muslim stronghold in Andalusia, to the Catholic King Ferdinand II of Aragon
The Capitulation of Granada, 1492, Francisco Pradilla y Ortiz. The Surrender of Granada: The last king of Granada, Abu Abdullah Muhammad XII, hands over Granada, the last Muslim stronghold in Andalusia, to the Catholic King Ferdinand II of Aragon

The union enabled exploration, conquest and a vast colonial empire. Without Aragon and Castile together, the resources for that expansion might have been lacking.

Fear of Muslim expansion helped motivate the union. Constantinople’s fall reinforced the Ottoman threat to Christian Europe, while Granada’s conquest became a symbolic Christian victory.

5. Russia might not have united

Greek priests arriving in Russia

The fall of Constantinople in 1453 had a profound impact on Russia and its subsequent development. Ivan III, the Grand Prince of Moscow, saw an opportunity to assert his authority and claim the title “Ruler of all Rus.” He was able to triple his territory and create a centralized state, effectively ending the rule of the Mongol Empire over Russia.

Losing Byzantium also changed Russia’s religious and cultural identity, leaving Orthodoxy in need of a new spiritual centre.

Moscow’s growing power made it a candidate. Ivan III presented himself as a new Roman emperor and Moscow as the Third Rome, successor to Rome and Constantinople.

Refugee artists, scholars and theologians brought Byzantine learning and traditions that shaped Russian culture and religion.

Without the fall, Orthodoxy might have stayed centred on Constantinople, and Russia might not have become a major European power.

6. A modern-day Roman Empire?

A modern day Roman Emperor

Byzantium was already weak and disordered after centuries of decline. Even surviving the Ottoman attack was unlikely to bring a recovery.

Still, a surviving Roman state at Constantinople’s Europe-Asia crossroads might have built a powerful navy and joined the Age of Discovery.

It would have faced competing European powers, changing global trade and difficult social, political and economic problems.

It might nevertheless have shaped world history, connecting East and West and encouraging regional peace.

The actual fall closed that possibility, leaving the alternative uncertain.

Too weak to survive in 1492

By 1492, Byzantine weakness made collapse inevitable, however intriguing the alternative.

Earlier turning points may offer more fruitful questions: no Latin sack of Constantinople, or a Byzantine victory at the Battle of Manzikert.

More historical what-ifs:

Read next Byzantine Empire weapons: 8 tools of warfare and survival

Back to the top

The History Hogs newsletter

Get historical stories and new articles in your inbox.