Could Alexander the Great have conquered Rome?

Editorial artwork: History Hogs
In this article

Could Alexander the Great have conquered Rome before it became an empire? Rome was still a rising power when he died, leaving room for a very different encounter from the later battles between Roman and Macedonian armies.

This hypothetical campaign compares Alexander’s strengths with the problems Hannibal later faced in Italy.

The question is not simply who could win a battle, but who could turn victory into control of Rome.

Did Alexander the Great want to conquer Rome?

Map of the Empire of Alexander the Great
Map of the Empire of Alexander the Great.

When Alexander died in 323 BC, his empire stretched from Greece to India. He was already preparing further conquests.

His western targets were Carthage and Rome. Carthage, in modern Tunisia, had a powerful navy and wealthy trading network. Rome was still rising in Italy, but Alexander saw it as a potential rival.

He had sent envoys demanding Carthage’s submission. When the city refused, he remained determined to conquer it and take its wealth and resources.

Rome was a more distant target, although plans to invade Italy and defeat it were already taking shape.

His sudden death at 32 ended those plans and left his empire in disarray.

A longer life would have given him the chance to pursue them. Whether he could have succeeded is the counterfactual at the heart of this article.

Rome in Alexander’s time

Map of the Roman Republic in 279 BC. It shows Rome as a small regional power on the Italian peninsula.
Map of the Roman Republic in 279 BC. It shows Rome as a small regional power on the Italian peninsula. / Wikimedia Augusta 89 

The Roman Republic, founded in 509 BC after the monarchy’s overthrow, had expanded slowly across Italy. By Alexander’s time it was an important regional power.

It had conquered most of central and southern Italy and become the region’s dominant state, but had not yet extended its conquests beyond the peninsula.

Rome was fighting the Samnite Wars against the peoples of the central Apennines. Running from 343 BC to 290 BC, those conflicts seriously tested its military strength.

The strength of the legions

As Rome expanded into the East, battles with the Macedonian-style Phalanx were common. However, this was over a century after Alexander’s death. The forces they faced also lacked the elite cavalry units that made Alexander’s army so formidable. These later Greek forces were no match for Rome.

The Roman army used the Camillian system and a chequered manipular formation. Units could manoeuvre quickly and respond to changing battlefield conditions.

These were citizen soldiers. Legions were raised locally when needed, rather than maintained as permanent forces.

The later Marian reforms, in the late second century BC, would introduce a professional standing army and reshape the legion.

Comparisons with the Second Punic War

The Second Punic War (218 - 202 BC): Rome took advantage of a mercenary revolt to obtain Corsica and Sardinia from Carthage. General Hamilcar Barca for his part occupied part of the Iberian Peninsula to establish his bases in Cartagena (Novo Carthago). When his son Hannibal Barca attacked Saguntum (Saguntum), an ally of Rome, in 218 the war resumed. Hannibal crossed the Pyrenees, then the Alps with an army of 50,000 men and several dozen combat elephants. The losses were heavy, but when the Carthaginian army arrived on the Po plain, it received support from the Gauls. Victorious on Ticino (Ticinus) and Trebia (Trebia), Hannibal crushed the Roman army at Lake Trasimene (Traesinum) in 217. Rome was only saved thanks to the skill of the dictator Fabius Maximus Verrucosus Cunctator who avoided engage in the decisive battle in the open countryside and is content to harass the Carthaginian troops. In 216, the army of consuls Caius Terentius Varro and Lucius Aemilius Paullus was destroyed near Cannae (Canoe). But Hannibal, who lacks men and materials, cannot exploit this success and reaches southern Italy, without succeeding in raising the people against Rome. Only the Greeks of southern Italy and Sicily gave him their support. Rome then goes on the counter-offensive. The Scipio brothers attacked Spain and the relief army commanded by Hasdrubal Barca (Hannibal's brother) was defeated in 207 on the banks of the Metaurus. Elected consul in 205, the young Scipio Africanus arrives in North Africa where Hannibal is recalled. The decisive battle took place at Zama in 202. The rallying of the Numidian horsemen from Massinissa to the Romans allowed Scipio to crush the Carthaginian army. Peace was signed in 201, removing its fleet and its empire from Carthage.
Map showing the major battles and troop movements of the Second Punic War. / Wikimedia Commons Pinpin

About a century after Alexander’s death, Hannibal brought another powerful army into Italy. The Carthaginian invasion became one of Rome’s greatest tests.

The Second Punic War lasted from 218 BC to 201 BC, as Rome and Carthage fought for control of the western Mediterranean.

Hannibal crossed the Alps, defeated Roman armies and won support from Italian city-states.

The success of Hannibal

His Italian campaign produced a succession of major victories.

He defeated Rome at Trebia in 218 BC, Lake Trasimene in 217 BC and Cannae in 216 BC.

At Cannae, around 50,000 Carthaginians surrounded and destroyed a Roman army of 80,000–100,000, inflicting one of Rome’s bloodiest defeats.

Hannibal’s double envelopment is celebrated as a brilliant manoeuvre and credited as the earliest recorded pincer movement in the Western world.

Several Italian city-states switched their allegiance from Rome to Hannibal. Even so, he never captured Rome itself.

The Fabian strategy

Hannibal rides a war elephant through a crowded mountain pass.
Hannibal Crossing the Alps; detail from a fresco by Jacopo Ripanda, ca 1510, Palazzo dei Conservatori (Capitoline Museum), Rome / © José Luiz Bernardes Ribeiro Wikimedia Commons

Rome responded with the Fabian strategy, named after Fabius Maximus.

Rather than risk another major battle, its forces harassed Hannibal, disrupted his supplies and wore his army down.

The approach drew criticism, but helped Rome survive the early war and eventually defeat Hannibal.

Alexander’s siege tactics

Siege of Tyre based on the ancient authors and aerial photos
Siege of Tyre based on the ancient authors and aerial photos / Vissarion, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Alexander might have been harder to contain with that strategy. His army had developed considerable siege expertise, demonstrated at Tyre in 332 BC.

Tyre stood on a fortified island off the coast of modern Lebanon. Alexander built a causeway from the mainland and brought siege engines against its walls, eventually taking the city.

He could therefore attack strong fortifications as well as move quickly in response to threats and changing tactics.

Could Alexander the Great have defeated Rome?

Alexander would likely have succeeded against the Rome of his own lifetime, still a growing regional power rather than the dominant state it later became.

His army had fought experienced opponents across different kinds of terrain while building an empire from Greece to India.

A victory comparable to Hannibal’s at Cannae would have given him a chance to move quickly against Rome itself.

His troops were probably more experienced than Roman legions still developing their formations and tactics. His ability to inspire loyalty and discipline would have been another advantage.

Those strengths, combined with siege expertise, could have enabled him to capture Rome and become the Mediterranean’s dominant power.

More on Alexander’s life and campaigns:

What if Alexander the Great had captured Rome?

Marble bust of Pompey the Great
Pompey the Great made his name by conquering many Hellenistic kingdoms that succeeded Alexander the Great. Pompey the Great, mid-1st century. BCE, Ny Carlsberg Glyptotek, Copenhagen / Richard Mortel from Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, CC BY 2.0 via Wikimedia Commons

Capturing Rome would raise another question: could Alexander keep it?

The Mediterranean might have come under Macedonian control, or conquest might have triggered further wars and prevented a later Roman Empire.

The legend of Alexander grows

Adding Rome to his conquests would have increased Alexander’s already formidable reputation.

Pacifying Italy and the prospect of revolt

Persia’s experience of imperial rule had helped Alexander conquer it relatively smoothly.

Its people were accustomed to a powerful central government. Alexander could replace the rulers of an existing empire rather than build one from scratch.

Italy presented a different problem: a patchwork of city-states with distinct political systems and cultures.

Bringing them under lasting control would have taken decades, much as Rome later needed to pacify Gaul and Hispania.

Without a strong central government, Macedonian control would probably have ended in revolt after Alexander’s death.

Rome in the wars of the Diadochi

Diadochi map. The Macedonian Empire, 336-323 B.C. AND Kingdoms of the Diadochi in 301 BC and 200 BC. Historical Atlas by William R. Shepherd, 1911. Courtesy of the University of Texas Libraries, The University of Texas at Austin.
Diadochi map. The Macedonian Empire, 336-323 BC. AND Kingdoms of the Diadochi in 301 BC and 200 BC. Historical Atlas by William R. Shepherd, 1911. Courtesy of the University of Texas Libraries, The University of Texas at Austin. / Wikimedia commons Diadochi PT.svg: Luigi Chiesa

A conquered Rome would likely have been drawn into the wars between Alexander’s former generals, the Diadochi.

After his death, their struggle over the empire brought decades of conflict and instability.

The political and cultural differences between Macedon and Rome would probably have created a similar struggle over the Italian territories.

Competing factions could have kept the region unstable for years.

No Roman Empire?

One possible result is that the Roman Empire never emerged.

Rome’s empire drew on wealth Pompey the Great took from the eastern Hellenistic kingdoms. A more divided Rome during the Hellenistic age would have found those conquests harder.

Rome might consequently have played a much smaller part in European and Mediterranean history.

More alternate histories:

Read next Julius Caesar achievements: 16 moments that shaped Rome

Back to the top

The History Hogs newsletter

Get historical stories and new articles in your inbox.