Essential technologies help deliver and secure the site.

Optional analytics and advertising cookies are disabled on this site.

Read about cookies and privacy

What if Julius Caesar had not been assassinated?

Editorial artwork: History Hogs
In this article

What if Julius Caesar had survived the Ides of March and continued to shape Rome?

His longer rule could have meant new conquests, different political alliances and more time to prepare his heir Octavian, the future first emperor.

The possibilities lead to a different version of Roman history.

1. Reprisals against the conspirators

Vincenzo Camuccini: The Death of Julius Caesar
Vincenzo Camuccini: The Death of Julius Caesar

Surviving the attack would probably have brought immediate reprisals against its organisers.

While Caesar was known for his leniency and forgiveness, the assassination plot directly attacked his authority and life. It is unlikely that Caesar would have taken such a threat lightly, especially since many of the conspirators were people whom he had forgiven or pardoned in the past.

In reality, many assassins died in the civil wars after his murder. A surviving Caesar might have dealt with them directly, probably seeking revenge and punishment.

Other opponents would have worried too. Continued rule would have meant more concentrated power.

Supporters of the Republic’s traditional order would have seen that as a threat, so opposition and attempts to remove him would probably have continued.

2. No civil war

Caesar’s murder brought turmoil and war. Antony and Octavian fought the conspirators led by Brutus and Cassius.

The costly, bloody conflicts shaped the future Empire.

His survival would probably have prevented those wars. An established power base and continued leadership could have avoided the succession vacuum.

A new triumvirate?

The First Triumvirate of the Roman Republic (L to R) Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus, Marcus Licinius Crassus, and Gaius Julius Caesar.
The First Triumvirate of the Roman Republic (L to R) Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus, Marcus Licinius Crassus, and Gaius Julius Caesar. The first Triumvirate played a key role in the death of the Roman Republic / Wikimedia Mharrsch

Octavian and Antony would not have needed an alliance against the conspirators. The heir could have continued training for leadership while Antony remained a powerful commander.

Together with Caesar, they could have formed a strong triumvirate preserving peace.

Avoiding the civil wars would have saved lives and resources and spared the Republic their long-term damage.

Rome could then have directed resources towards expansion and other priorities.

3. Roman invasion of Parthia

Map of the Roman Republic's empire and vassal states, 1st century BC.
Map of the Roman Republic’s empire and vassal states, 1st century BC. / Wikimedia commons Historicair, Ifly6

Julius Caesar was a man who lived for conquest and glory, and his ambitions extended far beyond the borders of Rome. At his death, he was planning an invasion of Parthia, a formidable enemy that had previously defeated Rome.

Alexander inspired him, and he wanted to outdo his former ally Pompey.

His invasion would have achieved far more than Crassus’s disastrous defeat by Parthia.

Caesar’s strategic ability and lessons from earlier failures would have prepared him for the terrain and cavalry.

The defeat by Crassus at the Battle of Carrhae is one of the worst in the history of Rome.

Success would have fulfilled his wish to follow Alexander and crowned his military career with a conqueror’s reputation.

The outcome cannot be certain, but he would probably have captured large eastern territories. Even partial success against Parthia would have made him unassailable at home.

4. Caesar’s death and Octavian’s succession

An old Julius Caesar on his deathbed

Survival would not have meant immortality. Already ageing and unwell, Caesar would eventually need a successor, even if he avoided the immediate civil wars.

Octavian could have continued learning under him. A planned transition might have made succession more orderly and peaceful.

More time with Caesar would have given him experience and preparation.

Antony might have stayed east to continue the Parthian war, allowing Octavian to secure Rome without his rival’s military intervention.

An agreed succession would probably have made relations between Roman factions more peaceful.

Domestic priorities could have benefited from resources otherwise consumed by war.

Could Augustus have been weaker?

Portrait of Augustus

Avoiding war might nevertheless have weakened Octavian’s eventual position.

At Caesar’s death, he lacked his adoptive father’s standing and legitimacy.

The real civil wars helped establish his authority and credibility.

Defeating Antony and consolidating power won public support and secured his place as first emperor.

Future civil wars

Without those tests, he might have struggled to prove himself and faced stronger challenges from rival factions.

Furthermore, Augustus’s long and prosperous rule brought peace and stability to the Roman world. The establishment of the principate system, which centralized power in the hands of the emperor, allowed for greater efficiency and effectiveness in governance.

His tax, infrastructure and administrative reforms also improved ordinary lives and strengthened the Empire.

6. Conquering Germany

Der siegreich vordringende Hermann" ("The Victorious Advancing Hermann"), by Peter Janssen, completed in 1873, depicting Hermann (Arminius) at the Battle of the Teutoburg Forest in 9 CE.
Der siegreich vordringende Hermann” (“The Victorious Advancing Hermann”), by Peter Janssen, completed in 1873, depicting Hermann (Arminius) at the Battle of the Teutoburg Forest in 9 CE.

With more training under Caesar and without civil war weakening him, Augustus might have tried to conquer Germany and avenge Varus’s defeat at Teutoburg Forest.

He was experienced but reluctant in command, with successes in Gaul and Spain and a preference for delegating to Agrippa. Service with Caesar in the East could only have strengthened that experience.

Avoiding civil war’s costs might also have supplied a larger army for Germany.

Success there would have strengthened his rule, expanded the borders and secured resources and trade routes across a large part of Europe.

It would probably also have cemented his standing as a conqueror.

Failure remained possible. German terrain and weather posed serious obstacles, and its peoples were capable, determined fighters, as Teutoburg Forest showed.

Defeat could have weakened his rule and encouraged other enemies.

7. Would much have changed?

Julius Caesar on the throne

Despite the possibilities, much of Rome’s history and the Republic’s decline were probably inevitable.

Corruption, disorder and an ineffective Senate had already encouraged powerful commanders such as Caesar and Augustus.

Roman expansion was also approaching its limits when Caesar died.

Centuries later, Hadrian withdrew from distant territories because governing lands across Europe, North Africa and the Middle East cost too much.

Caesar’s death began a transition already encouraged by Republican institutions struggling to manage expansion. Augustus secured his power through a more stable, centralised government better suited to the Empire.

Want more alternate history?

Read next Cicero and Cleopatra: Republic, monarchy and mutual suspicion

Back to the top

Follow History Hogs

Follow History Hogs via RSS